Comics/Graphic Novels Games

Fashion Disasters: Roy Harper

Fashion Disasters: Roy Harper

Some comedian guide characters who’ve been round for many years have iconic costumes which have stood the check of time. Some have progressed by way of a collection of trendy ensembles to mirror their ever-changing time durations.

And a few, apparently, dress at midnight.

Right here on Fashion Disasters, we’ll showcase these poor slobs who simply can’t appear to get it proper. First up: Roy Harper!

[Note: I originally wrote this post before Heroes in Crisis began. Though I hate to kick a hero when they’re down, please know that the following mocking comes from a place of love. Also, white superheroes from the ’40s never stay dead, so I’m pretty sure that within the next five years Roy will be back with us, and almost certainly dressing as disastrously as always.]

Roy was first launched method again in Extra Enjoyable Comics #73 (November 1941) alongside together with his mentor, Inexperienced Arrow. As Ollie’s child sidekick Speedy, he dressed precisely like his mentor however in purple:

And, like, it’s wonderful, I assume? The outsized belted T-shirt and leggings combo could be very a lot what I wore as slightly child within the ’90s, however hey, it’s reasonably priced and cozy! He’s accessorized with the hat (LOVE), dishwashing gloves, and a pair of trainers borrowed from Dr. Destiny, with whom he and Ollie shared a ebook. It’s an uninspired copy of what was already a boring costume, however it’s not appalling.

After his notorious battle with drug habit within the early ’70s, Roy modified his look barely to a wrap prime with a daring décolletage. Once more, it’s not horrible, however all these strains battle—the diagonal straps of his quiver, the black define of the wrap, the belt, the hem of his shirt. Though, contemplating a number of the newer outfits he’s worn, I in all probability shouldn’t be complaining about too many strains with this one.

(Additionally please take pleasure in Roy’s extraordinarily correct description of being 13.)

Oh, Roy. Oh, Royford. Oh, my candy summer time baby. What are you doing? Roy’s first costume beneath his huge boy codename Arsenal options a number of the worst developments ’90s comics needed to supply, together with nonsense pouches, a headsock with the highest reduce off to let his hair flutter within the breeze (there are costumes the place I like this, however, like…in case your chin wants safety, why not your cranium?), and armor the place armor shouldn’t be—on this case, a solitary crossbow-laden forearm. Additionally, huge ol’ armpits. And fingerless gloves. And I’m fairly positive that’s a boomerang on his chest and never an arrow. This can be a mess.

Then again, he’s the one dude on this cowl who doesn’t have a mullet, so it might be worse.

This costume (which I’ve all the time regarded as soccer padding although that’s alleged to be a metallic breastplate, for some unexplained cause) manages to someway be each ugly and boring. Like, the purpose of streetwear as a superhero costume is that it’s at the least trendy? Or snug? However this manages to be visibly neither whereas additionally combining all of the non-matching browns Roy might discover.

A supervillain appeared into Roy’s thoughts and determined he needed to be identical to his then-dead foster dad, so he gave him a fancy dress precisely like Ollie’s, however in purple. That is truly a incredible costume…as a result of it’s Ollie’s. However in purple. That is type of a theme for Roy.

That is in all probability one of the best costume Roy ever had that wasn’t a direct copy of Ollie’s. Or, no less than, it appeared actually hanging when drawn by its unique designer, Rick Mays…and type confused when drawn by anybody else? (The primary one above is the Mays model.) However Roy tried. Even when it strikes me as actually out of character that Roy put that arrow pointing up and never down.

Please word that that is additionally the beginning of Roy’s obvious contractual obligation with DC to include a douchey aspect into his costumes ceaselessly. On this case, it’s the 24/7 sun shades.

“Realistic” streetwear acquired actually well-liked within the early-to-mid–2000s and Roy went impartial with this look. It manages to be each boring (pants, jacket, zzzz) and overly busy (these boots!!!), however it’s high-quality. No matter. His belt is a robotic and as an archer he’s going to actually remorse not defending the within of his higher arms, however the brief sleeves + holster straps do issues to his shoulders that I’m definitely not complaining about.

However. The soul patch. The souuuuul paaaaaaaaatch. Why, Roymund, why?

And we’re again to copying Ollie once more! It’s bizarre that when Roy joins the Justice League, Hal provides his greatest good friend’s son an similar costume to Ollie’s, however about 3 times too tight, proper? With an enormous R on his belt buckle to see strain him into altering his codename to “Red Arrow” to be extra like Ollie? Like Hal’s midlife disaster is taking the form of roleplaying his personal youth together with his pal’s son? It’s uncomfortable, proper? It’s not simply me?

Anyway that R is tremendous douchey so we’re three for 3 on the contractual obligations, nicely accomplished.

A part of me needs to offer Roy a cross right here as a result of he’d simply had his arm ripped off, his daughter was horribly killed, he fell off the wagon drug-wise, and he was working for a supervillain. One other a part of me needs to tug this costume to hell as a result of all the things I simply stated within the final sentence was a few of the worst stuff DC’s ever achieved. The remainder of me is aware of that objectively talking, this costume is…fairly dangerous.

The masks is ok. The collar is ok. The golden robotic arm is…impractical, given how tender a metallic gold is, however so is capturing arrows at criminals with weapons, so fantastic.

However OH MAN YIKES @ the remainder of it, huh? The large triangle strap poking into his photo voltaic plexus…is that purported to be an A? Why does he want one other one on his belt? Why are they each primarily Aquaman’s emblem? I do know he’s again to being Arsenal right here however there are different methods to stylize an A! What’s purported to go in that huge searching horn flap on his proper thigh? That knife in that man’s chest again there? Why does he have 5 thigh-knives after which one awkwardly bigger one? What’s with the ski poles on his again? Do males perceive that should you put an elastic band round your thigh after which weigh it down with 2–four knives, it won’t keep round your thigh? Why is his belt buckled over his knife holsters?

That is additionally an excellent instance of one thing that a whole lot of Inexperienced Arrow artwork falls sufferer to, which is that these bizarre arm straps Ollie began sporting within the ’70s aren’t simply to provide him awkward tan strains. They’re meant to guard his internal arms from the discharge of the bowstring, which signifies that the strong half ought to be on the within of Roy’s arms, not the surface. You simply misplaced one arm, Roy, don’t slice the meat of your forearm off the opposite one.

Lastly, in reply to that narration field: no, Roy. It’s not a lot better.

Brace yourselves, as a result of I’m about to say one thing good about one among Roy’s New 52 costumes, however…that is truly a bit higher than the final one. It clearly attracts its inspiration from the earlier look, however using two distinct shades of pink plus the touches of gold break the entire thing up a bit and make it look much less arbitrary. The hip quiver is a factor actual aggressive archers use, and although I don’t assume it really works for somebody who does lots of backflips whereas he archeries, it’s clear that some thought was put into this design. Like all New 52 costumes, it has approach too many little strains throughout it, and he’s nonetheless sporting his bracers backwards, and are these spats? However truthfully, it might be worse.

However the hat. Why? Who checked out this costume and thought, “You know what it needs? A TRUCKER HAT”? Why did they hate us?

That is the dumbest factor I’ve ever seen.

Positive, bizarre preppy armor and a throwing star on his face, why not? I’ll say that I recognize that that is probably the most Robin Hood (or Will Scarlet, I assume) Roy has appeared since he final dipped one in every of Ollie’s costumes in cherry Kool-Assist, nevertheless it’s additionally so egregiously pointless that I’m livid. Though…no less than he’s not Jason.

Why would you set yourselves up for a fart joke like that? Why is Roy sporting an armored tankini over his Beneath Armour? So many questions.

This outfit is again however extra “tribal-y,” I assume? I’m so drained.

I’d like to notice that Roy went via at the very least six costumes in 5 years however by no means removed the rattling hat.

Oh no, see, he turned the hat round now. And he’s received wraparound shades, too, so we’re doubly douchey! Boy, that’s simply gilding the lily, isn’t it?

I don’t know what to inform you guys. I really feel like a damaged report at this level. There are too many strains. There are pointless pouches. His bracers are nonetheless on backwards.

(In case you’re questioning if Roy has ever had an unquestionably good, really private costume: sure. It was on the Teen Titans cartoon, and it was superb.)

by way of GIPHY

Roy. On the danger of sounding like your mom, you’re a good-looking younger man within the prime of your life! You have got such a reasonably face! Please, for the love of Locksley, get your self into a greater costume and let your mild shine. You deserve it!

And when you’re at it, burn that hat.

Signal as much as The Stack to obtain E-book Riot Comedian’s greatest posts, picked for you

By signing up you comply with our Phrases of Service

Do you want podcasts like This American Life, RadioLab, or Planet Cash? Annotated is kinda like these, however for books. Go right here to seek out out extra, or click on the picture under:


fbq(‘init’, ‘729442010451189’);
fbq(‘monitor’, “PageView”);(perform(d, s, id)
var js, fjs = d.getElementsByTagName(s)[0];
if (d.getElementById(id)) return;
js = d.createElement(s); = id;
js.async = true;
js.src = “//”;
fjs.parentNode.insertBefore(js, fjs);
(doc, ‘script’, ‘facebook-jssdk’));